Sales

Personal Injury Intake: Speed, Screening Questions and the Follow-Up That Signs Cases

Personal injury intake from the firm's side: how fast top firms respond, what after-hours coverage looks like, the screening questions that qualify a case on the first call, a 14-day follow-up cadence, and getting the agreement signed the same day. Benchmarks are one vendor's published data, labeled as such.

Alexander ChuaCo-Founder, Growigami November 16, 2026 11 min read

Personal injury intake is the stretch between an injured person reaching out and a signed contingency agreement. It decides more of a PI firm’s growth than almost anything in the marketing budget, because the firm has already paid for the inquiry by the time the phone rings. If nobody answers, the money is gone.

We read the top Google results for “personal injury intake” in November 2026. Most were intake forms: a questionnaire builder, PDF intake sheets from individual firms and a form template. One AI voice vendor wrote a useful piece on the first 90 seconds of a call. What none of them covered is the firm-side system around the form: how fast top firms answer, how they cover nights and weekends, how many times they follow up, and how they get the agreement signed before the caller talks to another firm. That is this guide. For the general law firm version, including Clio’s secret-shopper study of 500 firms, see our law firm client intake process guide.

What do the benchmarks say about personal injury intake?

Independent PI intake data is scarce. The most detailed public set we found comes from Pioneerly’s personal injury benchmarks, read on 16 November 2026. Pioneerly sells marketing services to personal injury firms, so treat these as one vendor’s published figures, not industry statistics. It compares the average US PI firm with the top 25%:

Intake benchmark (Pioneerly)Average firmTop 25%
Time to first response to a web inquiry15.7 minutes (office hours)Under 2 minutes, by phone and text, day or night
Firms that never respond to web inquiries26.5%0%
Firms replying within 5 minutes25.5%93.6% or more
Unanswered calls25.6%Under 4.7%
After-hours contacts answered by a personNot given96.3%
Follow-up attempts per lead1 to 29 to 14, by call, text and email over 13 to 31 days
Booked consultations attended81.4%98.6%
Consultations that become signed cases34.3%66.0%
All inquiries that become signed clients10.6%21.7%
Time from first contact to a signed agreement3.2 daysSame day, signed electronically

Two notes from Pioneerly’s own page. Each stage uses a different sample, so you should not multiply the stage rates together. And it says 33.7% of all inquiries arrive after hours, with weekends at 14.3% to 21%.

The figure that stands out is consultation to signed: 34.3% at the average firm against 66.0% in the top quarter. Pioneerly puts the average fee per case at $16,538 in the same data set. At that fee, every case that slips between consultation and signature is a large loss, which is why speed and signing are the two places to work first.

Speed: answer every inquiry like a ringing phone

Calls get answered because phones ring. Web forms and chat messages often land in an inbox nobody watches. The fix is plumbing, not headcount:

  • Route every form, chat and text to the same alert as a call, with the caller’s number and what they wrote.
  • Reply by call and text at the same time. Many injured people will not pick up an unknown number; a text saying who you are and that you are calling back gets the next call answered.
  • Set one target and track it. “Every web inquiry gets a call and a text within five minutes” is a target a manager can check every morning.

If you advertise heavily, check where your calls go during campaign spikes. A queue of three callers on hold is three callers dialing the next firm in the search results.

After-hours: decide in writing who answers

Accidents happen at night and on weekends. Pick one of three models and write it down:

ModelHow it worksWatch for
Live answering service or in-house night shiftA person answers every call and takes the facts using your scriptScript quality and hand-off speed to the morning team
Software answering with a person on callSoftware answers, texts back and collects facts; an intake specialist on call phones serious matters back the same eveningThe software must say it is automated and must not give legal advice
Text-back plus morning callbackAn automatic text confirms the message and gives a callback timeOnly acceptable if the morning callback really happens first thing

If you use AI voice software, know the rule that applies to the technology: the FCC ruled on 8 February 2024 that calls using AI-generated voices are “artificial” under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) points lawyers using generative AI to the rules on competence, confidentiality, communication and fees, and notes that confidentiality protections extend to prospective clients’ information. Check with your counsel and your state bar before you launch anything automated. Our AI outbound calling guide covers how voice agents work and what they cost.

The personal injury intake questions that qualify a case

The PDF intake sheets that rank for this term run to 15 pages: employment history, children, prior settlements, every doctor. That is useful after the case is accepted. On the first call, ask only what the attorney needs to decide, in this order:

  1. What happened, in your own words? Let them talk first. The caller is often hurt and stressed; listening is the first qualifying step.
  2. When did it happen? The date drives the statute of limitations, which varies by state and type of claim.
  3. What kind of incident, and where? Car or truck crash, slip and fall, work injury, dog bite, other.
  4. Were you hurt, and have you seen a doctor? Treatment, and when it started.
  5. Who do you think was at fault? Their view, plus whether a police or incident report exists.
  6. Which insurance companies are involved, yours and theirs? Carrier names are enough for now.
  7. Have you spoken to an insurance adjuster or signed anything? Statements and releases change the case.
  8. Have you talked to or hired another lawyer about this? The firm-made PDF forms we read ask this near the top, along with whether the earlier lawyer signed a release.
  9. Who else was involved? Names of the other parties, for the conflict check.
  10. How did you hear about us? Required, every time. This is how you will know which channels sign cases.

Two rules for the person asking. Do not tell the caller whether they have a case; the attorney decides. And end every call with a specific next step: “An attorney will review this and call you by 4 pm today.” Under ABA Model Rule 1.18, information from a prospective client stays confidential even if the firm does not take the case, and the rule refers to avoiding more disqualifying information than is needed to decide. That is another reason to keep the first call focused. Your state’s version may differ.

A 14-day follow-up cadence for personal injury leads

If the first attempt does not connect, the case is decided by the attempts that follow. Here is a cadence close to the “9 to 14 attempts” pattern in Pioneerly’s top quarter:

WhenAction
Day 0, within 5 minutesCall; if no answer, text and email at once
Day 0, +1 hourSecond call
Day 0, eveningThird call or text, outside working hours when people are home
Day 1Call and text
Day 2Call at a different time of day
Day 4Text with a direct number and a booking link
Day 7Call and email
Day 10Text
Day 14Last call and a closing email with how to reach the firm

Counting each call, text and email, that is up to 14 touches over two weeks. Stop at once if the person asks you to; ABA Model Rule 7.3(c) bars soliciting someone who has made known a desire not to be solicited, and TCPA rules on calls and texts apply as well. Whether each step of a cadence is allowed under your state’s rules is a question for your ethics counsel. For no-shows on consultations, call within 15 minutes of the missed time and offer the next slot.

Signing: close on the same day

Pioneerly’s average firm takes 3.2 days from first contact to a signed agreement; its top quarter signs the same day, electronically. Days in between are days for a second firm or an insurance adjuster to reach the caller. To shorten it:

  • Have the attorney review new matters at set times every day (for example 11 am and 4 pm), so no case waits overnight for a decision.
  • Prepare the contingency agreement for e-signature before the attorney calls, so it can go out during the call.
  • Walk the client through the agreement on the phone and stay on the line while they sign.
  • Send a welcome message within the hour: who their contact is, what happens next, and what to send you (photos, the police report number, medical bills).

What is better intake worth? A worked example

Use your own numbers in this formula:

Extra signed cases per month = monthly inquiries x (new inquiry-to-signed rate - current rate)

Extra fees per month = extra signed cases x your average fee per case

With example inputs (not benchmarks): 120 inquiries a month, a current inquiry-to-signed rate of 10% and a target of 14%, and an average fee of $12,000:

120 x (0.14 - 0.10) = 4.8 extra signed cases a month. 4.8 x $12,000 = $57,600 a month in fees.

Then check cost per signed case (marketing spend divided by cases signed). If spend stays flat and signed cases go up, cost per signed case falls, which our cost per lead entry explains at the lead level.

What to measure every week

MetricTarget to set
Median minutes to first response, by channelYour own target, such as 5 minutes for forms
Unanswered calls, day and nightAs close to zero as you can staff
Attempts per unreached leadYour cadence, checked lead by lead
Consultations attended / bookedRising month over month
Signed / consultationsThe gap Pioneerly flags as the biggest
Days from first contact to signedSame day as the goal
Cost per signed case, by sourceFalling, or holding as volume grows

For the vendors behind most of this software, ABA TECHSHOW in Chicago is where intake, CRM and answering-service companies exhibit each year.

If you want this run for you

Growigami puts AI agents on the work and our CMOs on the result. For a personal injury firm, that often starts with the response and follow-up above, then search, social, paid or your website. You pick the process; each starts at $1,999 a month, with a 3-month minimum and 30 days’ notice, and you approve everything before it goes out. See how it works for law firms.

Frequently asked

What is personal injury intake?

Personal injury intake is the firm's process from the first call, form or chat from an injured person to a signed contingency agreement: answering, capturing the facts of the incident, screening the matter against the firm's criteria, booking the attorney review or consultation, and getting the agreement signed. It is usually run by intake specialists, with an attorney making the decision on the case.

What questions should a personal injury intake ask?

On the first call: what happened and when (the date matters for the statute of limitations, which varies by state), the type of incident and where, the injuries and whether the person has seen a doctor, who may be at fault, the insurance carriers involved, whether a police report was made, whether they have already spoken to or hired another lawyer, and the names of other parties for a conflict check. Detailed medical, employment and damages history can wait until after the case is accepted.

How fast should a personal injury firm respond to a new lead?

In minutes. Pioneerly, a marketing firm that sells to personal injury practices, publishes benchmarks showing the average firm's first reply to a web inquiry takes 15.7 minutes in office hours and 26.5% of firms never reply, while its top quarter replies in under two minutes by phone and text, day or night. Treat these as one vendor's figures, but the direction is consistent with other lead response research.

How many times should intake follow up with a personal injury lead?

More than most firms do. Pioneerly's benchmarks put the average at one to two attempts per lead and its top quarter at nine to fourteen attempts by call, text and email over 13 to 31 days. A workable cadence is several attempts on day 0, then days 1, 2, 4, 7, 10 and 14, stopping at once if the person asks you to.

Should intake staff tell a caller whether they have a case?

No. Intake gathers the facts and an attorney decides. Intake staff should not give legal advice or predict outcomes. Their job is to capture the facts, show the caller they have been heard, and set a clear next step and time for the attorney's call back.

Can a personal injury firm use AI for intake?

Many firms use software to answer after-hours calls, texts and chats and to collect facts. Some rules to check with counsel first: the FCC ruled in February 2024 that AI-generated voices count as artificial under the TCPA, ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) covers lawyers' use of generative AI including confidentiality, and ABA Model Rule 7.3 restricts live person-to-person solicitation. States adopt their own versions of the Model Rules, so check your state bar.

Alexander Chua

Co-Founder, Growigami

Decade running growth at B2B SaaS. Co-founded Growigami to ship the work every week.

Start with one process.

We learn the business and build your first go-to-market process on us this month.